Update:
Comodo’s CEO Attacks Scot’s Newsletter Product Decision
January 22nd, 2008
Comodo’s president and CEO, Melih Abdulhayoglu, used his forum today as a podium to blast this Scot’s Newsletter Jan. 20th blog post. In that post, I notified readers here of my decision to stop considering one of the two modes that his company’s software firewall product, Comodo 3, offers during installation.
Abdulhayoglu, in his forum post, never directly comes out and admits that Comodo 3 Basic Firewall doesn’t have anti-leak protection. That’s part of the problem! My readers weren’t aware that this was the case because I wasn’t aware until SNB commenters drew my attention to it. I then asked Comodo for verification of that fact — and got it.
At this writing, I am unable to find a document on the Comodo Web site that provides a features/functionality comparison of Comodo 2.4, Comodo 3.0 Basic Firewall, and Comodo 3.0 Advanced. Without that information, Comodo’s users are left to guess.
My concern was that my readers might guess that they had protection with Comodo 3 Basic Firewall that they do not, in fact, have. So I moved to make that point clear. I just wish I had made the point sooner.
My only responsibilities are to the interests of my readers and to being as accurate as I can be. I believe I’ve met both goals.
– Scot
Complete Article: Scot’s Newsletter Blog
Edit: Please see Comodo’s topic for their side of it.
How would you rate Comodo Personal Firewall? and what to improve?
Now, I and Egemen had a chat (phone call) with Scott last week about our firewall. There we explained its capabilities. At no stage did we say CPF has no “outbound leak protection”!!! I am surprised that he just ran that story with that misunderstanding. Very sad indeed! Obviously Scott must have misunderstood some of what we said. Of course CFP v3 in simple firewall mode has “outbound protection” and a pretty good one too! The Leak resistance (eg: protection against malware killing the firewall etc) comes from Defense+ (which is built into v3!).
Also Online Armor forums:
An extraordinary post from the CEO of Comodo: Our Response